Ensure you select the setup that aligns perfectly with your gardening objectives and matches your site’s environmental factors.
Key Takeaways
- Elevated planting areas provide excellent soil management, simpler upkeep, and increased defense against insects, rendering them perfect for limited spaces or difficult ground situations.
- Subterranean gardens are more cost-effective, simpler to enlarge, and ideal for bigger or multi-level layouts—particularly when the indigenous soil is in good condition.
- The choice between these options relies on your gardening objectives, available space, and soil conditions; each approach can flourish with proper maintenance and configuration.
When you imagine your ideal garden, you likely conjure up a specific vision in your head, regardless of what that might be.
potager garden
or an
English cottage-style garden
Regardless of your intentions, remember to take several factors into account to decide which gardening approach suits your circumstances best. The quality of your soil, available area, and specific gardening objectives will dictate whether you should opt for raised garden beds or direct planting in the earth.
Our specialists clarify the distinction between elevated garden beds and in-ground gardening along with the advantages and disadvantages of both techniques to assist you in choosing the best option for your needs.
How Does a Raised Garden Bed Compare to In-Ground Gardening?
Sara Rubens
, a certified garden coach and the founder of Seed to Sanctuary, points out that raised garden beds are constructed above the ground using materials such as wood, metal, or stone. These beds are particularly beneficial when the local soil quality is inadequate, drainage issues arise, or there are constraints related to space and movement.
“She explains that in-ground garden beds are planted directly into the natural soil. These are ideal choices when the earth is either already fertile or has potential for improvement. In-ground beds tend to be less expensive, accommodate deeper roots, and hold water more effectively,” she states.
She recommends that for in-ground gardens, one should conduct soil tests regularly, add compost frequently, and apply mulch. For raised beds, she suggests using a nutrient-rich soil mixture containing compost and ensuring consistent moisture through the use of a drip irrigation system.
At What Times Is It Appropriate to Utilize Elevated Planting Boxes?
Laura Janney
The gardening expert and CEO of The Inspired Garden Masterclass states that you should choose a raised garden bed if the current soil conditions are subpar, full of stones, or polluted.
“A elevated garden bed works well if you prefer a neater and more confined appearance. Additionally, remember that raised beds are simpler to fence off, particularly if wildlife tends to invade your garden,” she advises.
Advantages of Elevated Planting Boxes
Expanding in elevated planters
They can simplify the process due to offering greater control. ” Raised beds provide superior soil management, enhanced drainage, and a pleasing look,” explains Ruben.
Let’s delve further into the advantages that raised garden beds provide, which you can anticipate enjoying throughout the growing season.
Total Soil Control
Nicole Johnsey Burke
The founder and CEO of Gardenary Inc. explains that using raised beds provides complete control over the soil, eliminating issues with compacted clay and concerns about contaminants in the earth.
“You have the chance to begin anew with an enriching, organic soil blend where your plants can flourish. With this strong base, you’ll see a reduction in weeds and much less frustration. In the past, I would dedicate many hours to weed removal from my in-ground beds. Nowadays, all I do is add some compost to my elevated planters every season before getting back to collecting produce,” she explains.
Ease of Care
Burke highlights another significant advantage of using raised beds: they simplify garden maintenance. She notes that “the soil remains loose and manageable compared to compressed ground-level beds, eliminating the need for large, bulky tools. My toolkit consists only of a hori hori knife, pruning shears, and a small hand rake,” as she elaborates.
She adds, “You’re also reducing the amount of bending and kneeling required, leading to greater comfort, extended time outdoors, and increased enjoyment throughout. With no need for digging or tilling, you can focus solely on planting and harvesting within an area that feels pleasant to occupy.”
Increased Protection
If you find it challenging to keep pests and pets away from your garden, a raised bed could be an effective solution. According to Burke, raised beds serve as a physical obstacle not only for inquisitive children and roaming pets but also for various garden pests.
“The high walls assist in keeping out rabbits, slugs, and even digging animals such as moles and voles when installed correctly. It’s akin to providing your garden with its very own small stronghold,” she explains.
Disadvantages of Elevated Planting Boxes
Here are several drawbacks you should keep in mind before heading to your nearby garden store for supplies needed to construct a raised garden bed. We’ll explore the negative aspects of this particular gardening technique.
More Costly to Start
Even though gardening involves costs, Rubens notes that constructing raised beds might be expensive initially. This is because you have to buy materials like wood or metal to create them. You could attempt to lower these expenses by looking for free resources online; however, this varies based on local availability. Additionally, purchasing extra soil to fill the beds contributes further to the overall expenditure.
Difficult to Expand
One significant drawback of raised garden beds highlighted by Janney is that after construction, expanding or modifying their design becomes challenging. Given that these beds utilize different building materials, your available growing area ends up being restricted. To increase the size for extra planting space, you would likely need to dismantle sections of the current structure or construct new beds altogether.
Growing Some Plants Can Be Challenging
Another point Janney highlights when choosing between raised garden beds and in-ground gardening is the difficulty in cultivating deep-rooted plants if the bed isn’t sufficiently deep. “Think about the kinds of flowers and
veggies you wish to cultivate
“If you’re looking to cultivate tomatoes, I suggest using a raised bed; but for crops like corn or melons, you’d be better off planting them directly in the ground,” she advises.
Another thing to consider is that aggressive and invasive plants can rapidly overtake the area as well.
At What Times Is It Appropriate to Utilize In-Ground Garden Beds?
Sometimes, opting for in-ground gardening can be preferable over using raised beds. According to Janney, if your native soil is of good quality and you desire a bigger area with greater flexibility, an in-ground garden might be ideal. In-ground planting works well if you aim to develop a multi-layered layout, like an English cottage garden, or wish to experiment with techniques such as chaos gardening.
Benefits of In-Ground Gardening
Although elevated garden beds offer advantages, ground-level gardens may prove superior in certain situations. Below are the top reasons why professionals prefer cultivating plants directly in the soil of a garden bed.
Increased Room and Possibilities for Gardening Layouts
A significant advantage of in-ground gardening over using raised beds is the increased ability to customize your garden design as desired. According to Janney, this setup provides greater space for root development, particularly beneficial for bigger plants and bushes.
If your aim is to transform your backyard into an edible oasis filled with different types of fruit trees and shrubs, consider spreading them throughout your yard instead of confining them to a raised bed.
Simpler to Extend and Reconfigure
Janney tells us that in-ground gardening is significantly simpler to expand and modify compared to raised garden beds. Because raised beds are constructed with fixed dimensions, they restrict the available area, making it challenging to increase their size or alter the layout of your garden. Conversely, in-ground gardens can readily extend past their initial boundaries.
Cons of In-Ground Gardening
Greater space and creative possibilities might make in-ground gardening the preferred choice for numerous gardeners. Nonetheless, there are several downsides to be aware of that can assist you in making a well-considered choice about what kind of garden suits you best. Consider these points before starting to plant your cherished veggies and blooms.
Tougher to Maintain Soil Health
For in-ground gardening, you begin with the soil as it is, which can make maintaining its health challenging. According to Janney, if your soil becomes contaminated, correcting this issue will take considerable time. Additionally, the soil might lack optimal conditions for the specific plants and blooms you intend to cultivate and could necessitate amendments.
amended with nutrients
, otherwise you’ll be limited to plants that flourish under those circumstances.
May Be Challenging to Keep Up With
Because these gardens are essentially at ground level, maintaining them can pose greater challenges. According to Janney, in-ground gardens run a higher risk of weed infestations spreading from nearby regions. In contrast to elevated planters which provide better defense, planting directly into the soil makes it significantly tougher to safeguard your flora against animals and insects.
Deciding whether to cultivate your plants in raised garden beds or stick with conventional in-ground gardening hinges on various aspects like your budget, preferred design, among others.
“Either type can prove fruitful with appropriate attention, so I recommend selecting one according to your soil conditions, available space, and gardening objectives,” Ruben advises.
Read the initial article on
Real Simple
